All Buyer's Guides
AmazingRibs.com does not make or sell anything, but we love toys and we are happy to share our opinions of them.
Smoker Reviews & Ratings
How To Buy A Smoker Overview
Charcoal Smokers
Egg, Kamado, Ceramic Grills/Smokers
Large Capacity, Restaurant & Trailer Smokers
Electric Smokers
Gas Smokers
Pellet Grills/Smokers
Stovetop Smokers
Pig Roasters
Wood Burning Pizza Ovens
Grill Reviews & Ratings
How To Buy A Grill Overview
The Differences Between Charcoal & Gas Grills
Charcoal Grill Reviews & Ratings
Egg, Kamado, Ceramic Grills/Smokers
Pellet Grills/Smokers
Gas Grills
Tailgate Grills & Portable Grills
Grills Gone Wild
More Reviews & Ratings
Thermometers & Thermostats
Barbecue Accessories
Kitchen Tools
Outdoor Kitchen Planning
Cookbooks, Magazines, Videos
Barbecue Sauces
Bar Necessities
Corkscrews
Funny Aprons, Hats, T-shirts, Tschotschkes
Meathead's Favorite Ingredients
Photography Gear
How We Review Products
We purchase many products we review although occasionally suppliers send us samples. We make it clear in our reviews when we are working with a sample. Here's a key to our reviews.
 |
We have hands-on experience testing this product. We have also gathered info from the manufacturer, owners, and other reliable sources.
|
 |
We have seen this product up close and we have also gathered info from the manufacturer, owners, and other reliable sources.
|
 |
We have researched this product from afar by gathering info from the manufacturer, owners, and other reliable sources, with our BS meters on high.
|
Reviewers
Many reviews are by Meathead, the author of most things on this website. In 2011 Scot Murphy and Gordon Hubbell joined him to help with the Buyer's Guides. The author of each product's review is named at the end of the writeup.
Best In BBQ Medals
Best In BBQ Gold, Silver, and Bronze Medals are given only to products that we highly recommend based on price. Awards are based on features, quality, and value. Price is an important factor. Rarely will a $400 Gold Medal be in the same league as an $800 Gold Medal, so it is important that you read the reviews. Rest assured that when we award a medal, it is because we are impressed by it for the price, not because someone has paid us to say so or because the company is an advertiser or sponsor. Manufacturers: Click here for permission to use these medals in ads and on packaging (there is no charge) and for info on how to get a high resolution version.
About Model Numbers
Manufacturers often make slight variations to their basic model exclusively for certain merchants. For example, a grill manufacturer might make their Firebrand Grill Model ABC123 with cast iron grates available only on Amazon. Meanwhile, the ABC125 is identical except it has stainless steel grates, and it is sold only at ACE Hardware. Of course the prices can differ.
Your Amazon Purchase Supports This Site
When a product is available on Amazon.com, we often provide a direct link. Amazon often has the best prices anywhere, even better than many manufacturers' websites because manufacturers know that if they undercut retailers like Amazon, they may drop the products. Amazon also offers fast delivery (often free), no sales tax (in most states), gift wrapping (on many items), and painless refund policies. Check out Amazon's Gift & Wish Registry .
Amazon pays AmazingRibs Inc. a small referral fee when you purchase from them after clicking on a link on this site, so purchasing from them helps underwrite the cost of operating AmazingRibs.com.
If you like all the info we give you for free and would like to help us buy charcoal, please copy the link below and save it. It takes you to Amazon.com and tags things you buy with the AmazingRibs code so we get that referral fee. It works on anything from grills to diapers and it has zero impact on the price you pay. http://tinyurl.com/3rlglce
|
This unique guide shows you both USDA recommended temperatures for all your favorite meats as well as the temperatures recommended by chefs (they are not always the same). This 8.5" x 5.5" magnetic card can be attached to your fridge or grill, or both! Click here to see more of of the information packed into this indespensible guide.
|
How they work:
Thermocouples: The best instant read and all-purpose thermometers
Thermocouples are the good food thermometers because they're fast. Some thermocouples can read accurately in fewer than 2 seconds, faster than any other sensor. They're thin: They have 2 thin wires in the probe, so the tip can be very small and thin. The sensitive area is very close to the tip so you know just what you're reading and they can be used to check the temp in several locations easily. They're accurate: They're margin of error is less than 1%. Some can be calibrated. You can get thermocouples that are great for instant metering, or others that can be left deep inside a roast like a pork shoulder or a ham for hours.
Thermistors: Good for continuous readings for large roasts and oven thermometers
Thermistors are digital thermometers with a small resistor in the tip. They are not as quick as thermocouples, they tend to be thicker, but they can be very accurate. Some have a leave-in probe on a wire that allows you to insert it into the meat and get the readout from outside the oven so you can monitor the meat temp continuously.
Bi-metal dial thermometers: Just not reliable
Most bi-metal coil dial thermometers should be called heat indicators, not thermometers. These dial-and-needle readouts use two strips of metal bonded together and rolled into a coil. Each metal expands at a different rate, turns a shaft and this provides the reading on a dial.
They are slow and because the helix can be 0.5" long or more it is not as precise at reading a specific location as the tiny sensor in the tip of a digital. I don't recommend them for measuring food or air temp.
Most thermometers built into grills and smokers are bi-metal, but they are often low quality in order to keep the grill price down. Also, these grill themometers are mounted in the dome where the temp can be very different from the temp at the cooking surface making them both unreliable and misleading.
They can easily become unreadable if they fill with smoke and or water. If you get condensation or water under the glass of a bi-metal thermometer, put it in a zipper bag with a couple of cups of rice or dried pasta and seal it up. In about a week the grain will have absorbed the moisture and your thermometer should be back to normal.
Some bi-metal thermometers are rated as oven-safe and can be inserted into meat and left in during cooking, but the sensitive area may be up to one inch or longer, so they are useful only for meat thicker than 4", such as pork shoulders.
Now that I have slammed bimetals, I should tell you that there is one brand that a lot of the pros use on their big pits and they tell me it is pretty accurate. Tel-Tru. It comes with a wingnut, a range from 150°F to 700°F, 1.75" dial, and a 2.13" stem. As good as they are, that dial face is just not as accurate as a numeric readout that is precise to within a degree or two.
Other thermometers: Not recommended for cooking
Old-fashioned liquid filled thermometers are very accurate so they make good oven and refrigerator thermometers, but they cannot read a small area such as the center of a hunk of meat well, and they are very slow.
Don't trust popup thermometers
You want to take your turkey off the cooker when the thickest piece of meat is 160°F and let it rise to 165°F. You cannot trust the popup thermometer that comes inserted in the bird. According to How Stuff Works, the plunger that pops up is anchored in metal that melts at 185°F. At 185°F a turkey breast is more particle board than party. We do not want our meat to go above 165°F so that 20°F difference is the difference between succulence and sucky.

|
Bloody chicken problems
Food scientists are reporting that even when cooking chicken well past the safe temp there still may be red juices. Dr. O. Peter Snyder of the Hospitality Institute of Technology and Management reports that the industry claims this is because "Chicken is so young - 6 1/2 weeks at slaughter - and the bones are too porous, even though the animal is large enough to be sold for food." He goes on to say that "Because the objective of the industry is to grow chickens as rapidly as possible, it is doubtful that this blood and color problem will be solved in the near future. It would be probably more efficient to teach consumers to eat bloody chicken, if cooks can convince consumers that they have a thermocouple and know how to use it to validate pasteurization." In other words, you cannot tell if chicken is safe by merely looking for clear juices as is said in most cookbooks.
|

I'll tell you where to stick it
Most grills come with cheapo thermometers that can be off by as much as 50°F. They are an afterthought to manufacturers and are usually bought bulk from cheap producers. To make matters worse, the probe is located high in the dome well above the food. You need to know the temperature at the grate, where the food is. So put the probe right next to the meat, being careful not to touch the meat (it is cold) or the grate (it is hot).
Place your digital thermometer probe 1 to 2" above the cooking surface but don't let the tip touch the metal of the grate which is hotter than the air surrounding it. Some thermometers, like the Maverick, come with a handy clip that does the job just fine. If you don't have a clip, use a small potato, a radish, or a wine cork. Make sure the tip, where the sensitive parts are, protrudes from the veggie. Don't use a wine cork in very hot parts of the grill, it can catch on fire and damage your probe.
Some probes come with a metal clip that holds it just above the grate. After I lost my clip drilled a hole in a cork to hold the probe. It works fine for low and slow cooking but it has an annoying tendency of catching on fire under high heat, so I often jam the probe through a small potato or radish. Just make sure the tip of the probe in not touching the cork/potato/radish/meat/grate or you won't get an honest read. Also be careful that the tip is not within 1" of the meat. The air surrounding it is cooler than the rest of the oven.
Listen to this email from a reader "I had been clipping the probe on the underside of the upper rack. That had the probe about 3" to 4" above the top of the meat. My food was taking much longer to cook than your recipes say. So I tried the probe in that location for about 1/2 hour and then moved the probe to the cooking surface, clipping it to the cooking grate about 4" to 5" below the previous location. The difference in temperature was about 25 to 30°F cooler at the cooking grate location! I never would have believed it! So in actuality, when I thought I was cooking at 225 to 230°F, I was actually cooking at 195 to 200°F! No wonder everything was underscooked!"
Get grommets (but no Wallaces)
One of the problems with a lot of grills is that you have to thread thermometer cables under lids and hoods and then find a way to attach the probe to the grates without letting the tip touch the metal. The lids often crimp or cut the cables.
On a Weber Kettle or Smokey Mountain you can dangle them through the vent hole, but you're never quite sure where the tip of the probe is and if it is touching meat or metal. Then you forget about it, lift the lid, and you thermometer goes flying into the neighbor's yard.
I put this problem to the folks at Maverick. I told them it would be nice if I could drill a hole in the side of a grill, like a Weber Kettle, and insert a probe. Within a day they wrote back and said you can order two temperature resistent silicone grommets, little silicone rings, perfect for the job. Just drill a hole in the grill, insert the grommet which fits snugly to the inside of the hole, and then push the tip of the probe through the hole. It will stay in place and hover above the lower grate at just the right height. To order 2 grommets, one for each grate on a WSM, send $6 (shipping included) to:
Maverick Industries, Inc.
94 Mayfield Ave.
Edison NJ 08837
Attention: Nijmeh
Our consulting physicist, Dr. Greg Blonder, says "The steel is very hard. Create a dimple to help center the drill by hammering a concrete nail or center punch into the side. I also cut a small block of wood to fit behind the spot you are drilling, clamped or held tight. Helps prevent shredding on the inside of the drilled hole, and drops vibration while drilling. Use a newer, sharp high speed bit."
|
Just how hot is it?
Insert the tip of the thermometer into the thickest part of the meat and go past the center. Slowly pull it out. Read the coldest temp. Here's are two other tricks for taking the temp of a thick cut of meat.
1) Line up the probe tip on the outside of the meat (that's a brisket below) until the point is past the middle. Then slide your finger tip until it touches the top of the meat (top photo). Now slide the probe into the meat until your finger touches the meat. The tip will be past the center (bottom photo). Now pull it back slowly and read the lowest temp. If any modeling agencies need a hand model my wife is available. Ain't that a purty finger?

2) Another option is to insert the probe from the side as in the porterhouse below. Use your finger to locate the center of the meat as above. Stay away from the bone which heats at a different rate than the muscle.

|
Thermometer calibration
Thermometers are essential tools. Buy good ones and take care of them. Here are some tips on caring for them.
Calibration. You should check a thermometer's accuracy soon after you buy it, then once every year, and again if you drop it. You can check your thermometer's accuracy with boiling water and with ice water.
- Boiling water. Bring a pot with about 3" of water to a boil and insert the probe. It should read about 212F. Notice the key word "about". The exact reading can vary slightly with air pressure (factory calibration is based on one atmosphere, about 30" of mercury). Minerals in tap water can cause minor variations, so use distilled water if you want to be absolutely precise. I just use tap water. Remember that water boils at lower temps at high altitudes. The ThermoWorks website has a nifty calculator that helps you determine what your boiling point is.
- Ice water. Fill a tall glass with ice cubes, not crushed ice, add cold water, and let it sit a minute. Insert the probe and make sure it is not below the ice or touching the ice. The temp below the ice can be several degrees above 32F (0C) and the temp of the ice can be below 32F. The experts at ThermoWorks say "Make sure the probe is in the middle of the ice water mixture and then gently stir for best results." The ice water test does not vary with altitude.
Malfunctions, troubleshooting, and some important warnings
Lately I have been noticing comments on Amazon from disgruntled thermometer buyers complaining their units have failed. They are mostly about thermometers with flexible cables. As I read their comments carefully, I have come to the conclusion that most of the problems are because the owners did not read the instructions or mistreated the cables.
Failures are usually probe or cable failures rather than electronics failures. With proper care, probes should last years. I have numerous braided cable thermometers (I test a lot of thermometers) and only one has failed and then it was after several years of abuse. I was able to buy a replacement at a reasonable price.
I raised the subject with a bigshot at Maverick and he told me this story: "I had a consumer drive [to our office]. He advised he got HHH on his probe [an error message]. I assembled unit and turned on. I saw the HHH. I pushed the probes into the transmitter a little harder to make sure they were making good connection. Solved problem. Consumer stood in my office with mouth open."
If the unit displays an error or cryptic message like HHH or LLL, let the probe tip come to room temperature. The error may have been because you exceeded the range of the probe. If you still get an error or false temperature, squeeze the plug jacks harder into the transmitter and twist them back and forth so they make better contact. If the problem still persists, remove the batteries and put them back in so the device can reset itself. If ther is still a problem, it is likely the probe wire has shorted out, not a failure of the electronics.
Order spares. Probes are like hard drives. They can fail and they will fail at the most inopportune times. Fortunately most are cheap. If you depend on your thermometers, and you should, keep a spare probe or two in inventory because you know for sure yours is going to die on Christmas Day when you are cooking a 16 pound Wagyu Prime Rib that cost you $400.
Keep them dry. Thermometer probes with braided cables like the ones on the otherwise excellent Maverick ET-732 occasionally fail if water gets into the place where the solid probe and the braided cable connect. That means you absolutely cannot submerge them when you wash them. The braid can get wet in a drizzle because the wires within are coated.
Cleaning. After using a meat probe, get a sponge wet with soapy water and sponge off only the tip that was in the meat. Then rinse under the faucet or with a wet paper towel being careful to keep water off the braid and especially out of the junction. To clean a smoker probe, use a soapy sponge and focus only on the lower 1" since the sensor is usually within the lower 1/4". You don't have to clean the smoker probe after every use, just don't let it build up an opaque coat.
Don't drop them. DOH!
Don't smash or crimp the cable. If the lid on a grill smashes the cable it can break the internal wire. Crimping it can also break the internal wire.
Don't leave them out in the rain. Many of the best digitals are not water resistant, no less water proof. If it looks like it may rain, put your meter in a zipper plastic bag.
Stay within the temp ranges. Pay attention to the specifications in the manual. Each unit has a temp range. Don't go over it! You can damage the probe.
All this raises the question: Why can't manufacturers come up with a fully submersible probe and cable? And those manuals! Would you please hire a professional writer rather than asking your English major daughter to write it? C'mon guys! Get with it!
|

Refrigerator and freezer thermometers
CDN Refrigerator & Freezer NSF Professional Thermometer. You need to keep your fridge between 35°F and 38°F to prevent frost buildup and keep your food safe. A liquid filled thermometer is the way to go here. They are pretty darn accurate, don't need batteries, and you don't need the speed of a digital. The CDN is low profile and has hooks to hang on the wire racks. Get two, one for the freezer, too.
|
Related articles
Click here for the internet's best guide to meat temps. Now, with a good thermometer, there's no more guesswork.
Magic happens within the meat at different temps. Click here to learn some basic meat science.
Click here to learn the thermodynamics of cooking.
Click here for a cooking log that will make you a better cook.
The first thing to do is season and calibrate your grill or smoker by doing a few dry runs without food.
|
Bi-metal dial thermometers are not reliable! As you can see, my highly arrurate digital thermocouple on the left shows my grill is cooking at 254°F while the unreliable built-in thermometer dial reads about 50°F less! That's a lot! So-called "instant read" bi-metal dial meat thermometers can take up to 30 seconds to read accurately. Digitals can read in 1 to 6 seconds with much greater precision.
Thermometer Buying Guide
By Meathead
"Bimetal coil thermometers are about as accurate as a sniper scope on a nerf gun." Alton Brown, Food Network Star, author of multiple cookbooks, Meathead's personal hero
A radio host once interviewed me and asked "What is the single most important advice you can give a barbecue cook?" My answer, without hesitation, was "Get one good digital thermometer for your cooker and another for your meat."
Most grills and smokers come with bi-metal dial thermometers, and they're usually crap. It is not unusual for this design from the 1700s to be off as much as 50°F like the one above (on an expensive and otherwise superb grill). You cannot trust them. I have readers tell me that when they bought a good digital from my list below that they learned their grills were off by as much as 100°F! This is a recipe for well done steaks, bloody chicken, late meals, cold food, embarassment, shame, and ostracism.
Cooking without good digital thermometers is like driving at night without headlights. Spend the money for good thermometers. Right now! They will pay for themselves by saving your meat and your face.
Without good digital thermometers there's a good chance you'll be making lame excuses for overcooked meat, undercooked meat, or, worst of all, apologies at bedside in the hospital as your guests recover from food-borne illness.
Here's what the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) says: "The color of cooked meat and poultry is not always a sure sign of its degree of doneness. Only by using a food thermometer can one accurately determine that a meat has reached a safe temperature. Turkey, fresh pork, ground beef or veal can remain pink even after cooking to temperatures of 160°F and higher. The meat of smoked turkey is always pink."
Dispelling some myths
I don't care what the TV chef said, you absolutely positively definitively without doubt no way nohow cannot tell anything about the temp of a grill is by holding your hand over the grate and counting "1001, 10002, 1003" until until your palm starts to smoke. Each of us reacts differently to heat, and the heat 1" above the grate can be significantly different than 6" above. Maybe an old pro who cooks 100 steaks a night can do this parlor trick, but most backyard cooks cannot.
Likewise, you may have also heard that you can tell the doneness of a steak by poking it and comparing the bounciness of the meat to the tip of your nose or the flesh between your thumb and forefinger. As if everyone's hand has the same firmness and bounciness! As if a filet mignon has the same firmness and bounciness of a sirloin! Lookit, almost all professional chefs carry a meat thermometer in their chef's coat. There's a reason.
And about those pop-up thermometers found in turkeys: They have a compound in the tip that melts at a determined temp and releases a spring that pops the stem up. Although they can be accurate, they can also stick, they read only one part of the turkey, and they are usually set too high. Pop-ups are why your turkey tastes like cardboard. Throw them out.
To be a good outdoor cook you need three thermometers:
#1 - You need an oven/grill/smoker thermometer
Can you imagine cooking indoors if your oven did not have a thermometer? Then why do you try to cook outdoors without a good oven thermometer? If you hope to be king of the grill, you've got to got to got to know what the oven temp really is. And this may come as a shock, but your indoor oven is probably waaaay off too. It probably needs adjusting. So if you buy a good oven/grill/smoker thermometer, you can improve your indoor cooking too. I recommend the the Maverick ET-732 or the Maverick ET-85, described below, because they are both an oven thermometer and a leave-in meat probe. Two for the price of one.
#2 - You need a food thermometer
The difference between a medium rare and well-done steak is pretty narrow. The diff between moist tender fish and dry chalky fish is even less. Seconds matter. And two pork chops sitting side by side can cook at different rates. The only way to deliver properly cooked meat to the table and protect against food borne illness is to take its temp. If you hate apologizing for overcooked meat or having to take bloody chicken off your guests' plates and sticking it in the microwave, then you've got to get a good meat thermometer. There are two types, instant read and leave-in. I recommend you have both, but if you get only one, go for a good instant read.
1) Instant read. These babies are great for spot checking when you have 10 burgers on. They all cook at a different rate. Or a piece of salmon with a thin part and a thick part. Or a turkey that has dark and white meat that cook at different rates. Just open the grill, poke a thin probe into the meat, and in seconds it tells you the temp. And don't worry about poking holes in the meat. It is 60 to 70% liquid, so if you poke a hole in a 16 ounce steak and it loses 1/4 ounce of juice, you'll still have 9.35 ounces of fluid left. A fast thermocouple is best for this task. I strongly recommend the Thermoworks Thermapen, which reads in 3 seconds and is extremely accurate. More info below.
2) Leave-in probe. A leave-in probe is inserted into thick cuts of meat and left there throughout the cook. It lets you monitor the progress of the cook without having to open the lid and stab the meat. They are essential for pork shoulder, hams, whole hog, pork loin, beef rib roasts, tri-tip, and turkey. I strongly recommend the Maverick ET-732 or the Maverick ET-85, described below, because they are both a leave-in probe as well as an oven thermometer. Two for the price of one.
#3 - You need a refrigerator thermometer
It is crucial for your budget and your health that your refrigerator be set properly. If your fridge runs too hot, food will spoil, need to be discarded too soon, and there is a risk of food-borne illness. Ideally we would like to freeze everything, because freezing either kills or incapacitates microbes, but the ice crystals that form when foods freeze can puncture and damage cell walls, so many foods are best if they are not frozen. Fruits, like strawberries for example, change drastically when frozen. Meat is altered, but not as significantly. Most fridges have a way to adjust the temp. The ideal temp is just above freezing, from 35 to 38°F. Below 35°F, frost may form and above 38°F, microbes grow too fast. Because the temp can vary from top to bottom and in the drawers, a good refrigerator thermometer that you can move around is important. A liquid thermometer is just fine for this task. It is pretty accurate and it will run forever since there are no batteries involved.
Thermometer shopping checklist
Here is a checklist of things to look for when you go shopping for a good thermometer:
Accuracy. Bad data is worse than no data, so it's important to know where the reading is coming from. For a food thermometer, you want the sensitive part of the meat thermometer to be small and in the tip of the probe. The temp just below the surface can be a lot different than the temp in the center of a chicken breast. For an oven thermometer, you want the temperature reading from right next to where the food is being cooked. A thermometer in the dome of your grill will not tell you the temp that the meat is experiencing 6" below the probe on the grate just over the coals. It can be a lot hotter down there. Dial thermometers are just not reliable and they are usually located way above the food (see the sidebar at right).
Speed to read. How long does it take to get a good reading? This is especially important for meat thermometers. When you open the lid on your cooker to stick the meat you are letting out valuable heat and humidity. You want a thermometer that gives you a quick read. Five seconds or less would be nice. The best work in two seconds or less.
Temperature range. If you're going to spend money on a thermometer, it would be nice if it could read the temperature of the meat, the oven, a hot grill, in your freezer, or in an ice bath, and in boiling oil.
Length of the probe. Meat thermometers need to be able to get the temp in the middle of big roasts such as hams and pork shoulders.
Thickness of the probe. A thin probe is easier to insert into the meat and leaves a smaller wound that seals faster. You don't need a gusher of valuable fluids following the probe out.
Adjustable. Some thermometers can be calibrated (see the info on calibration elsewhere of this page).
Water resistant and easy to clean. You don't need barbecue sauce and soapy water in the inner works. Braided cables can fail if they get wet or if they are crimped or if they are smashed by the grill lid.
Ease of use. Is it easy to read? If it has lots of buttons and settings, can you remember how to use them?
Price. There are some decent units for under $20 and others can cost almost $200 with attachments.
Sturdy. You want it to last. How's the warranty? And if it breaks, can I order parts? Will the manufacturer repair it promptly and for a reasonable price?
Timer. Although not necessary, some digital thermometers also have timers with alarms. Very handy.
Warranty and customer service. What is the warranty? Does the manufacturer have replacemet parts and sell them at a reasonable price? Do they have a good reputation?
Meathead's recommendations
There are hundreds of good digital thermometers out there and I have not tried them all. Below are the ones I have tried and that I recommend. If you don't see it here, I have either not tried it or I don't like it.
Thermoworks ThermaPen . This is the thermocouple thermometer you see all the cooks on TV using. I highly recommend it for anyone serious about cooking meat or baking bread properly. It reads meat temp in three seconds, is extremely accurate, has large easy-to-see numbers, and a long probe for getting into the center of a large hunk of meat like a ham. The thin probe will not open a gusher when you pull it out. It is on a pivot so it can reach into awkward places. The heat sensor is extremely small, so you know you are reading just where you put it. It is water resistent, reads from -58 to 572°F (-50° to 300°C), and switches between F and C.
Although it was designed to read food temps, it can even read air temp if you insert it through a hole in your grill or smoker, but it can take up to 30 seconds to give a good reading and you want to make sure you place it at the so the plastic body does not melt and the tip is near the food. It comes in a variety of colors.
Another nice thing about the ThermaPen is that the company stands behind it. My first (an older model) began to malfunction after eight years. Probably had nothing to do with the fact that I had dropped it half a dozen times. I called them, gave no indication that I was a writer, described my problem, and rather than hit me up for a repair bill, they told me how to fix it. My only real complaint is that it is hard to read at night. Made in England.
Click the red link above for current pricing and direct ordering of the from Amazon.com.
Maverick Pro-temp PT-100 Instant Read Thermometer . This recent release of the PT-100 is significantly improved over the previous version that I dunned because it was inaccurate. This one is much more accurate.
It is clearly inspired by the industry standard, the ThermaPen (above), but it is a little larger because it takes three AAA batteries (included) rather than the nickle sized battery in the ThermaPen. It comes only in gray and looks a bit more macho than the ThermaPen with black no-slip treads. The manufacturer claims the temperature range is -40 to 450°F (-40° to 230°C). There is a switch for switching from C to F. The one thing it does better than the ThermaPen is the LCD screen that is backlit and bright enough to read easily in total darkness, and it can be very dark inside a big pit late at night. There is also a small meat temperature guide on the side with which I have a few minor quibbles. Just as important, Maverick gets good marks for customer service in my book and from what I hear from readers. Click the red link above for current pricing and direct ordering of the from Amazon.com.
ThermoWorks RT600 . Super-Fast Pocket Thermometer.
This is a very good inexpensive food thermometer. It is not for measuring oven temp. It has a thin tip with a tiny thermocouple and it gives an accurate reading in six seconds.
It is small, lightweight, clips in your shirt pocket, waterproof, dishwasher safe, has a range of -40 to 302°F (-40 to 150°C). The waterproof part really got my attention. More than once I have dropped a thermometer in a pot of custard or bowl of chocolate, and then I get to lick it off before I throw it away. Not this one. Best of all, it is only about $20!
ThermoWorks RT301WA Super-Fast Pocket Digital Thermometer. The specs on this nifty thermocouple are pretty much the same as the RT600 (above) with a couple of interesting differences.
Same range, 6 second read time, thin probe, etc. Alas, it is water resistant, not waterproof, but it makes up for that by being calibratable so if it ever slips out of true, you can reset it.
Taylor Commercial Waterproof Digital Thermometer, at right, can fit in your shirt pocket and will hardly dent your rear pocket.
CDN Proaccurate . This stainless steel unit is said to be dishwasher safe, but I am reluctant to test that claim. Reads quickly and comes in a protective sheath. Recommended by Cook's Illustrated.
Maverick ET-732 Wireless Thermometer . Two thermometers in one, this very cool tool was introduced in January 2011. It replaces and significantly improves upon the earlier ET-73.
There are two probes and cables, one to insert into the meat and leave it in, and another to leave in your oven/grill/smoker. Both probes plug into a transmitter module that sends temperatures to a receiver module that you can take into the living room with you and place on the coffee table next to the beer and chips. That's right, with the Maverick you can monitor your grill and your meat while you watch the game. You can also set the timer to remind you when to start the side dishes or wake you up if the game is really boring, or set it for a target temp, and an alarm will let you know when the meat is ready.
Alas, the meat probe is not instant read and it is pretty thick. It can take up to a minute to correctly read the temp in a piece of meat, so you will still want something like one of the Thermapens for checking meat temp on steaks, chicken, fish, etc.
The new model is supposed to have a greater range than the old one, up to 300', but that's only through clear air. When I move indoors, the range is much less, and your distance will vary depending on what your walls are made from and how many electronic devices you have running. The new probes also can withstand more heat than the old model, up to 572°F, far better than the 410°F of the previous model. You can set it to read either Fahrenheit or Celcius.
There is a backlight so it can be viewed in the dark, both the sender and receiver have stands for easy viewing, and it also comes with a nifty clip that holds the oven probe just above the grill grates so it isn't misled by the tip touching metal. You can easily pop open the battery compartment of the receiver, but the sender's battery cover screws down over an o-ring to make it more water resistent so you will need a tiny Phillips head jeweler's screwdriver to insert the batteries, they did not include one. Many eyeglasses screwdrivers will work.
They solved the startup sequence issue: You can now switch on either unit in whatever order you want and if they don't sync up, there's a "resync" button on the back of the sender. This comes in handy if you wander out of range and then back in. There is now an alarm that tells you if you've gotten out of range of the sender, and there is a synch button in case the two units lose their link. And finally, you no longer have to remove the stand and battery cover to switch on the transmitter! The interface is fairly easy, but it's no iPhone. Keep the (much improved) manual handy in case you can't remember which button to push.
Maverick has good tech support. When my old receiver began to malfunction, they told me the problem sounded like a bad backlight and told me to ship it back for a replacement. No question about when I bought it. I never identified myself as a writer, so I am confident I got the same treatment as you would. Cables sometimes fray or malfunction, and the manual cautions you not to submerse them and the probes, so you should consider buying a spare set.
It is important to know that the food probe is designed for roasts and thick pieces of meat. You may not get accurate readings on thin steaks, chops, and other thin cuts. For those, I prefer the faster, thinner thermocouples. Click the link above for discount pricing and direct ordering from Amazon.com.
iDevices iGrill Barbecue Thermometer . What a really cool tool! Easily the best I have discovered in 2011. With some caveats.
The iGrill is a thermometer with a probe that can be used for meat or oven/grill/smoker temp. Switch it on, and it sends a Bluetooth signal to an app on your iPhone, iPod Touch, or iPad so you can watch the game while the roast is cooking, cut the lawn, or take a nap because you can set it to beep when one of the probes hits a target temp or time. There is a jack for a second probe so it can measure both your meat and your cooker or two dishes at once.
The base unit, a little larger than a deck of cards, is available in white or black, and has a convenient way to wrap the probe's cable around its body and store the probe so the cable doesn't kink and break and you don't stab yourself, both issues I have had with other thermometers. It runs on two AA batteries (included) and has a built-in display so you don't need to pair it with an Apple device, but the white model I have is almost impossible to read in bright daylight. I suspect the black will be easier to read. The manufacturer clainms it works up to 200 feet, but actual distance will depend on the thickness and material in your walls.
It has a folding stand that doubles as a hook so you can hang the unit from the side table on your grill or a nearby hook. It will only go from 32 to 400°F (0 to 204°C), so you need to be careful that you don't put it in a really hot grill. I have tested it against a lab instrument in a smoker and it is pretty close to precise.
The body does not have any buttons that protrude, it has three touch sensitive hotspots, so it can survive a light drizzle, perhaps even rain.
There are two apps, Classic and Pro, and it would be nice if they combined them into one. I prefer the Pro because it has more features and because it traces a line on a chart as temps fluctuate. You use the iPhone/iPad/iPod Touch settings to turn on Bluetooth and pair with the iGrill. This went pretty easily on my iPad 1, but I had problems pairing it with my iPhone. I went to their site and there was a video that showed me how to fix the problem. Nice.
You can export the data to an email attachment in pdf or csv (spreadsheet) formats. The csv file has readings every 2 seconds, the pdf is not very helpful because it is a snapshot of only the reading at only one moment. I find the csv download very helpful in developing recipes and I am sure that competition teams could use this to help perfect their methods and timing. You can also set timers and countdown timers. Only one prob: If you switch aps to check the score in the game, the graph breaks while you were gone.
You can name your probes in the Pro, name the alarms, switch from C to F, and you can set timers to remind you to add charcoal or to put the beans on. You can select preset temps for meats, but I disagree with some of the numbers. Fortunately you can enter your own preferences (click this link for a better meat temperature guide).
The manual is built into the app and they send updates, but this is not much help if you don't have an Apple device. Apparently there was a software bug in early releases that forced a recall, but that seems to heve been fixed. They are promising an Android version in 2012.
Maverick ET-85 Two-In-One Oven and Roasting Digital Thermometer with Timer.
Maverick has a nifty inexpensive oven/meat thermistor thermometer combo that does many of the same things as the ET-732 (above) for about 1/3 the price.
It lacks the remote telemetry system so you can't read your meat and oven while you're in the living room, but it can read temps from 32°F to 536°F, and that's good enough for most grills and there's darn few times when you need hogher temps than that. It's pretty simple to operate, and the scabbard for the probe is a nice way to store it.
Important note: Some of the manuals enclosed with this unit say not to use it on a grill and that it is an instant read only. Maverick assures me this is an error and it will be corrected.
Thermoworks TW362B Meat Thermometer/Timer.
This thermocouple and timer combo is pretty handy. The thermometer works from 32°F to 392°F, and the timer can be operated with the thermometer or separately.
The probe is 7", deep enough for any clod of meat you will cook, and the cable is thin enough that it can be slipped under the lid of your grill or through your oven door. The cables will withstand the heat of a hot grill, and you should not use this with grills or ovens running more than, say, 375°F, but most things you need to grill should be cooked less than that. It is also not waterproof, so you can't use it in the rain or snow. Best of all, it is cheap in price (but not build) at about $20 and replacement probes are under $10. I recommend buying a backup when you buy the unit. The whole unit can clamshell, and it has a magnet for mounting on the fridge or the legs of your smoker. I have mine stuck to the back of my kitchen oven.
Maverick Rotisserie Thermometer . Maverick also makes a thermistor that has a probe that can be inserted into meat on a rotisserie and read remotely. Hooking it up can be tricky, but once you get the hang of it, it works.
Weber Beeper Thermometer . This is a nice unit that has a single probe for the meat. It does not go high enough to read a hot grill/oven. But it does have a remote that you can take with you into the house.
K-Type thermocouples for pros, competition teams, and really serious cooks
Thermoworks makes several excellent thermocouple gauges that can take a wide range of specialty interchangable probes called K-probes. The meters are relatively cheap (the Mini at left is about $45), but the probes are expensive, $30 to $60. I have both meters below, but if you're on a budget, buy just the Mini and the three probes. The probes are described below. Available from ThermoWorks.
|
|

ThermoWorks Mini Handheld Thermocouple Thermometer #MTC (far left) is the instant read thermocouple meat thermometer I use the most. And I mean instant. It reads within 2 seconds.
It is a small splash resistant handheld meter that can work with more than a dozen plug-in probes. The meter is accurate to within 1°F from -83°F to 1999°F (-64°C to 1400°C)! The probe can be removed and replaced with a probe on a cable for leaving in a roast, or a different cable for leaving in the cooking chamber for measuring oventemp. This is a very versatile inexpensive tool. Available from ThermoWorks.
|

Two-Channel Thermocouple Thermometer with Alarm #TW8060 (near left) is my go-to for reading smoker and grill temps in more than one location. Or you can put an oven probe on one end and a leave-in probe on the other. It has an alarm that will go off if your oven exceeds your prefered temp or drops below, and ditto for the meat. Available from ThermoWorks.

|
 |
|
Fast Response Meat Probe #113-151 is the probe shown far left on the Mini. It is hypodermic thin so it can be used for burgers and thin steaks and reads in only two seconds. Max temp 482°F (250°C). Available from ThermoWorks.
|
|

|
|
Smoke House Penetration Probe #THS-113-178 can be left in the meat and the stainless cord is super heavy duty and will not fray. This cable is far sturdier than any other. But it is thick and will not fit under grill lids without letting air in. You need to have a hole to insert it through. It functions up to 662°F (350°C) so it can be used to measure hot ovens as well as meat. Available from ThermoWorks.
|
|

|
|
High Temp Flexible Ceramic Fiber-Insulated Probe #WD-08467-64 can be used for measuring really high oven temp up to 2500°F (1371°C). It is my standard for measuring the air temp in grills and smokers. Because it is flexible you can bend it and wrap it around things like grill grates. Available from ThermoWorks.
|
Thermostats
With the introduction of the BBQ Guru in 2004, we entered the thermostatically controlled cooker era. Regardless of the weather outside, just set it and forget it has come to the back yard, just like in your kitchen. Originally expensive, more modestly rpiced models are appearing. They all are designed for charcoal and wood fired grills and smokers, but I predict thermostats for gassers cannot be far in the future. Every pellet smoker/grill has one and they are a joy to use.
They all work on a simple feedback principle. A thermometer in the cooking chamber tells a blower to turn on and feed more air to the fire when the temp drops below the target. It then tells the fan to turn off when the temp gets too high. Simple.
But the devil is in the details. You need a tight cooker so air doesn't leak in or out. Weber Kettles and Weber Smokey Mountains work well, as do most ceramic and kamado grills.
BBQ Guru PartyQ. Introduced in October 2011, the PartyQ is a very clever inexpensive thermostat device made by BBQ Guru, the pioneering inventor of thermostat controllers for grills and smokers. Their high-end models are popular on the competition circuit, and I'm sure this one will catch on big with that crowd because it is simple and inexpensive. But it also belongs in your back yard.
You place the thermocouple thermometer probe into the cooking chamber and attach it to the cooking grates with its alligator clip. The other end is attached to a controller that you can set for whatever temp you want. The controller is attached to a small blower that turns on and off depending on the temp in the cooker. The PartyQ runs on four AA batteries. Its competitor, the iQue (below), needs to be plugged into a wall outlet.
The blower needs to go through a 1" hole in the grill below the charcoal gate. I had to drill a hole into my Weber Kettle. It fits into a hole in the bottom of a Weber Smokey Mountain without drilling, you just have to block off the other holes with aluminum foil or the heat resistant tape they include in the box. Their website lists a number of grills it fits. Many ceramic grills have ports built in for this type of device.
Mounting it is a cinch once the hole is located or drilled, then all you need to do is switch it on, set the target temp on the LCD readout, and place the probe near your meat. You want to make sure you have removed all the ash from the pit otherwise it can get into the fan and the fan may blow it all around and onto the food. Close the intake vents, but leave the exhaust vent open at least partially unless your grill is leaky, in which case you can close it. Set the temp you want in 1 degree increments (F or C), let it run for about 30 minutes to stabilize the temp, and you can put the meat on. You can read the actual temp with the LED. Once things are stabilized, you want to keep the lid on to keep excess oxygen from reaching the coals.
The PartyQ can be calibrated in case it ever veers from true. Just insert the probe in boiling water and push some buttons and it will lock in to boiling temp. It can also be set to read in F or C.
The only negatives: It is not water resistant, so if it is raining or snowing, you need to duct tape a plastic bag around it being careful not to block the fan. There is no backlight so you need a flashlight in the dark. You must keep the unit running so the fan keeps itself cool otherwise heat buildup could melt it. Leaving it run for long cooks will use up batteries, so rechargeables may be the way to go. You need to make sure the batteries don't die or your blower might melt and your pit could go out. Also, the installation instructions and manual look to be slapped together and could be better written, and it sure would be nice if they would make the type in the manual a little larger for old farts like Meathead. I actually needed a magnifying glass to read some of the instructions for the Setup Menu.
Best of all, the PartyQ sells for $129 plus $10 for special adapters for certain grills.
BBQ Guru DigiQ, CyberQ, and NanoQ. BBQ Guru also makes a number of more complex and feature-laden controllers. They have a dizzying list of features and options, some with the ability to read both the cooker and meat, multiple cookers and meats. Some can be programmed to start at one temp, rise to another, drop, and hold as well as change temps depending on the meat temps. They also sell adapters for practically any pit you can imagine, commercial, competition, and backyard. With optional probs, adapters, and accessories, they run $264 and up.
Pitmaster iQue 110. The Pitmaster iQue has a blower that puffs air through a 1" flexible tube. The tube attaches to a stainless steel bowl that covers one of the air intakes on the bottom of the grill. The thermometer probe has a gator clip that attaches to the cooking grate. The blower and controller must be plugged into the wall while although is an optional adapter available to plug the unit into a car battery cigarette lighter.
The setup begins by removing all the ash from the cooker. On my ancient Weber Kettle I had to wipe the bottom outside to block two of the three air intakes with heatproof tape, a small amount of which is supplied. The tape must be removed after the cook if you want to use the grill for normal high heat grilling, so you'll probably want to buy a roll of tape. On my Weber Smokey Mountain the bowl covers one of the inlets, and the other two dampers can be closed in the normal fashion. The bowl screws on easily with a toggle bolt. For kamado or ceramic grills, there is an adapter that fits the intake on the bottom.
On the Kettle I was then instructed to place foil on 2/3 of the charcoal grate above the air inlet to keep cold air off the meat and the temperature sensor. This is a bit of a pain. On the WSM the setup was normal. The controller unit comes with a rope to hang it from the grill's handle, but the heat from the body of the cooker could melt the controller, so I lay it on a chair. It is not rain or snowproof, and because the blower is in the middle of the controller, there's no way to protect it with a plastic bag.
Finally, you set the controller with a dial from 175°F to 375°F (F only). Unlike the PartyQ, there is no readout telling you what the actual temp is, but there are LED indicators that give you feedback.
It sells for $139.
Rock's Stoker is an incredible hi-tech solution. It has a thermometer that goes into the cooking chamber and sends the info to a digital controller. The controller turns on and off a blower that regulates the airflow to the charcoal combustion chamber and thus controls the temp extremely accurately.
You can even insert another probe in the meat and plug that into the controller. You can program the controller to manage the temp on a variety of criteria. You can set it cook high for half an hour and then drop the temp or the inverse. Or you can have it cut back the temp when the meat hits a mark. It can even be connected to a wireless router and you can even control it with your computer or smart phone's web browser. The manual was clearly written by an engineer, and the settings and menus were decidedly not designed by a user interface expert from Apple, and you still have to make sure your grill doesn't run out of fuel, but thermostats are where it's at, Jack. I would give it a gold medal if the programming were not so difficult. Hey, this is the age of the iPhone, Rock, can you make this a bit easier, please?
Infrared thermometer
Maverick Laser Surface Thermometer . Infrared laser guns are really kewl looking, but they are not a necessity for the outdoor cook. They are designed to read the temperature of a hot surface like a griddle or a frying pan. They are not good for reading meat temp nor can they measure the temp of a grate or the air inside a grill. You point the gun at a surface like a frying pan, pull the trigger, and it puts a laser beam on the target. Don't let the laser fool you, it is only a targeting aid, the actual surface being read is larger than the laser, so it cannot measure something narrow like the grates on your grill.
This model measures from -58 to 1022°F and it is powered by two AA batteries (included). It works best on dark surfaces and doesn't always read accurately on shiny stainless steel pans or liquids. But because cast iron is slow slow to heat up, I use mine occasionally to determine if my cast iron griddle is the right temp and for frying occasionally. Where it has really come in handy is for locating cold spots on exterior walls of my house and areas around my windows that leak. If you use a griddle or cast iron pan a lot, or an old house, then this is a useful tool. Otherwise, save your money.
|